Teens don’t dig Twitter, says teen; world implodes

gangofteens1It’s hard to say what’s more shocking — that the words of a 15-year-old Morgan Stanley intern lit London’s financial world on fire, or that no one before thought to ask teenagers what they think (and actually listen).

To backtrack, Morgan Stanley Research in Europe published a report called “How Teenagers Consume Media,” (PDF) consisting almost entirely of intern Matthew Robson’s thoughts. Though unscientific, the report prompted calls from dozens of fund managers and CEOs, and the volume of responses was five or six times greater than Morgan Stanley’s usual research, spokesman Edward Hill-Wood told The Guardian.

Much of the report is common sense — teens don’t listen to radio, they play video games in long bursts, they like viral marketing, but not billboards, they rarely pay for music and they don’t read newspapers — but the real shocker, apparently, is that teenagers don’t use Twitter.

“Most have signed up to the service, but then just leave it as they release [sic] that they are not going to update it (mostly because texting twitter uses up credit, and they would rather text friends with that credit),” Robson wrote. “In addition, they realise that no one is viewing their profile, so their ‘tweets’ are pointless.”

Actually, this is a pretty obvious observation. Twitter is a great tool for reaching out to people you don’t already know because of its bare-bones interface and semi-anonymous nature. We tech journalists like it because it’s useful for networking. But teens aren’t, and probably shouldn’t be, communicating with strangers. Of course, they’d rather interact with friends, and Facebook, which Robson praises in his report, is a better place for that.

It’d be nice to see some market research that backs Robson’s claims, but I don’t think the financial industry would be better served unless it completely refuted what the teen said. The report struck a nerve because it was so personal — one teen’s unfiltered musings. Maybe the lesson here is that investors and other Twitter-obsessed individuals should seek that out a little more often.

Next Story:
Previous Story:

Photo of Jared Newman

About the Author, Jared Newman

Jared is a freelance technology journalist based in Los Angeles. He covers all topics for VentureBeat, including digital media, social networking and mobile apps. Before going full-time as a tech writer, he earned a master's degree in journalism from New York University and wrote for a daily newspaper in Connecticut.

Elsewhere, Jared writes for PC World, Technologizer, GadgetCrave and The Escapist.

  • Couldn't agree more. Does anyone know what Twitter's churn rate really is?
  • No one can say for sure if what this boy claims are true but they are certainly plausible. Teens want to talk to their friends in privacy (they don't want their parents to know), and they are also surprisingly aware of the dangers of sharing private information.

    Twitter does have the option to lock updates, but that dumbs it down to a crippled version of facebook. Twitter is all about being unashamedly public.
  • GirlYouDontKnow
    corrrect, Im a teen and none of my friends even have a twitter account.
    We all have myspaces and facebooks account though. :]
  • Name
    I had informally polled Bay Area teens a few months back to determine a development and marketing strategy, and came up with the same conclusion. They have almost no interest in Twitter whatsoever -
  • jonnybryce
    It's not about being public. We teens aren't scared that people will see our updates, plenty of default pics, which can be seen through Google, are teens holding beer.

    It's the fact that Twitter is just the status part of Facebook. That's all teens know it as. So, what's the point? Just keep using Facebook.

    They don't know the benefits and don't care. They're not scared about privacy, Twitter has privacy settings anyway. It's the fact that it's just Facebook statuses to them.
  • Greg
    Teens have real friends, they don't need to rub their ego's via twitter. In essence they have better things to do.
  • ronwilliams
    Teens will get to Twitter, I bet it is approaching better than 10% of the active base now and will be 50% by the end of 2010. The Mogan Stanley teenager is one kid and appears to be our of touch with his own experience (his billboard comment is a big clue).
  • jd
    Quantcast has Twitter at 5% 12-17 year olds (vs 27% for Facebook). The Morgan Stanley is actually the one in touch.
  • ronwilliams
    I should clarify my comment, There are according the the U.S. Census ~25M 12-17 year old children in the U.S. and Territories. Quantcast says that 5% of Twitter's ~28M U.S. website users is 12-17 or about 1.5M Kids, Twitter's API will account for 50% more users than the Website sees so its going to be 2M-2.5M 12-17 year old kids using Twitter so its getting close to 10% of the US Teen Population. That number will likely grow at the same or faster rate than Twitter as a whole grows until it tops out which by all current signs will exceed 50% of the U.S. teen population sometime in 2010. Twitter is currently a unique service with broad appeal so there is no reason to expect its demographics to differ much from the U.S. Population and then 1st World Population as time goes on, so once Quantcast says 8% of Twitter's users are 12-17 that is the correct proportion of kids relative to other age groups in the U.S. (this is all based on the assumption Quantcast is accurate which it is likely close). Twitter is reaching Teens just fine, as more information related to Teens enters Twitter more Teens will get engaged. Once Teens figure out that Twitter makes texting on a cellphone free it will really take off (and so will cellphones that support Twitter clients).

    Anyone who thinks a 15 year old understands his behavior in terms of why he makes the decisions he does is asking to be misled.
  • Timmy
    Funny that it takes a youngster to nail Twitter. Fact is, Twitter is not all that great.
  • Hauser
    The amazing thing is how obsessive tech journalists are with Twitter. They're failing to realize how out of touch they are with the real, non-twittering, world.
  • spryka
    Twitter is like a breath of fresh air on the Social Media scene. I have been on it for just a few weeks now and I have met several interesting people. It is a platform to

    network with people you would like to meet in real life.

    KZ
    Mass Email Marketing
  • ronwilliams
    Time pans the article making good sense of the senseless Morgan Stanley Teen.

    http://www.time.com/time/business/article/0,859...
blog comments powered by Disqus