Web 2.0: Teens love Facebook and Apple, confused by Twitter

teenThe old fogies at the Web 2.0 Summit in San Francisco today tried to figure out what those crazy kids are doing with technology by interviewing a group of five Bay Area teenagers. The session, moderated by former Piper Jaffray analyst Safa Rashtchy, rambled and eventually degenerated to teenagers free associating on different companies (”Google?” “Simple!”), but the most compelling part for me was seeing their visceral dislike of Twitter.

Now, the “teens don’t tweet” idea has already been beaten to death by the tech press, and Twitter co-founder Biz Stone has already told us that he isn’t too worried about it. But it’s one thing to read about surveys and studies and another to see teens on-stage, talking about how they don’t see what the point is. None of them had positive feelings about the microblogging service; a few said they had tried it out and didn’t find it useful.

“If I were using Twitter, I would just say I’m sitting on a couch in front of a bunch of people,” one teen said, and it was clear he couldn’t fathom why he would do that.

Later, one of the audience members asked if the teens might reconsider their position when they’re older and need to promote something (which, by the way, is a dispiriting way to see Twitter’s purpose). They said they might about it, if they knew enough people using the service.

This may be obvious to many of you, but I was also struck by how isolated the teens seemed from all the cool new tech that Silicon Valley nerds are excited about. None of them owned an iPhone, or any of the newer smartphones. They still used Google for all their web searches and only seemed vaguely aware of Microsoft’s search engine Bing. And while almost everyone I know uses Gmail for their personal email, one teen (a boy) declared, “Hot girls use Hotmail.”

Instead, they were really excited about Facebook. Isn’t that site kind of uncool, now that it has been around for a while, Rashtchy asked. No, the teens replied, because they still feel the site’s popularity and mainstream awareness are growing.

The kids also had good things to say about Apple. One said Apple had “won” with it’s “I’m a Mac vs. I’m a PC” television commercials, while another declared, “Windows would be a good prison guard, because it always locks up.” (As you can tell, a couple of them liked to grandstand for the audience.)

So how seriously should we take all these comments? Do they represent the future of the web? Well, maybe not — beyond the obvious caveat that these are just five teens, The New York Times has noted that many of the most popular sites on the web have become hits through an adult audience, so the importance of teens may be overstated.

Next Story: Box.net wants to work with enterprise app companies, starting with Salesforce
Previous Story: 5 O’Clock roundup: Net neutrality wins, Windows 7 sorta wins, New York Times still futzing around with the comments

Bookmark and Share
Photo of Anthony Ha

About the Author, Anthony Ha

Anthony is VentureBeat's assistant editor, as well as its reporter on enterprise technology, cloud computing, and tech policy. Before joining VentureBeat in 2008, Anthony worked at the Hollister Free Lance, where he won awards from the California Newspaper Publishers Association for breaking news coverage and writing. He attended Stanford University and now lives in San Francisco. Reach him at anthony@venturebeat.com. You can also follow Anthony on Twitter.

  • No
    Wow, I never knew a group of 5 kids could mean so much, wait, it doesn't so this is a really stupid post.
  • Wow, I never thought of that! Well, except when I wrote the last paragraph of this post, which is about how it's silly to extrapolate larger trends from this.
  • No
    You didn't word it the way you seem to have an opinion about it and even making a post about this is very pointless in general.
  • Damo
    Twitter is great. it's about actual real info out there in real time. It's not about telling me what you had for lunch, maybe that's where the kids are confused. I mean they all tweet anyway, on Facebook. The good thing about twitter is there are no annoying apps that actually do nothing, no drunk photos or pictures of peoples babies and kids (I hope all these kids grow up to 'not minding' being all over the internet), you can sign under a fake name which means you have free reign to say what you want without worrying what people will think of you, or offending others.

    Twitter is quick and easy, it's like texting if you don't have a phone (I don't, some of us still exist). Facebook equals 'a great way to keep in touch' (where have I heard that before?) but it is keeping touch in public. Someone you don't know or like will eventually find you and know all about you. Slightly disadvantageous in my opinion.
  • If all a teen can tweet about is them sitting on a couch in front of a TV, that says more about their poor quality of life, not the usefulness of Twitter.
  • GetALife
    If you equate tweeting with quality of life, you need to get one.
  • The Quoted Teen (Armando) was actually referring to tweeting about sitting on the couch at the conference in front of the audience, not in front of a TV. According to them, TV is troublesome, and these Bay Area kids have better things going for them. I can't wait for them to run the show. As for them grandstanding, I thought it was highly appropriate, considering all the brandstanding going on at the conference. Teensploitation deserves what it gets.
  • Excellent point, Mr Larner! The big companies should be scared because these are the next tech leaders. The "kids don't tweet" argument is like the old "Why can't Billy read" argument. Little Billy will learn to tweet when he see's something useful come from it.

    Personally, getting these teens on stage looks like a marketing promo. See! Here's the future! Learn how to market to them, so you can own the future! Here kid, here's your $100 for two hours of marketing research. Intel cares about kids ...dollars.

    Wasn't there a question, "What if Facebook charged $1/mo." The answer "I'd move to MySpace". Telling.
  • Name
    Twitter's rubbish. Just for demographics sake im 24/m and would consider myself an early adopter of all good new technologies. Twitter is muck though. It's essentially the same as facebook's status updates, except without a load more functionality that facebook offers. Every single person i know has a facebook, a few have some other social network accounts, and maybe 3 have twitter, which they never use.
  • Fair enough re: thinking Twitter is rubbish, but I don't think you can extrapolate much from your own friend group. I'm 26 and I'd say 70-80 percent of the people I know are on Twitter, and almost all of them use it more than Facebook. Obviously, that's not representative of the larger population either.
  • Name
    I've heard so many references to Twitter that I must find out how to use it. My grandchildren introduced me to MySpace several years ago, but now they've moved on to FaceBook. It seems important to them to network, but I just wanted to keep up with things they feel strongly about. Those two venues, however, appear to be very limiting. It seems to me that Twitter must be a means to express an opinion of agreement or disagreement on a subject, or possibly just say It's a wonderful day. ??! Or is this Grammy just too far behind in the technical learning curve?
  • Meagan
    As a teenager I find this article a little discouraging. I'd like to say that I'm very technology oriented, and I know several other people in my age group that are similar. However, I don't think the lack of twitter mania among the younger generation has anything to do with a lack of awareness in what is going on in Silicon Valley. Most teenagers have at least 7 hour disconnection away from the internet world(school) and that leads to them not being able always keep an update on sites such as Twitter. On the other hand, Facebook's live feed syncs better into that schedule. In addition, Facebook keeps track of what is going on the lives of people in your life, as opposed to Celebrities and news organizations. Why have a twitter when you have status updates?
  • Tom Dikanhari
    Anthony, I love your use of the word "extrapolate",...Ha...Ha...
  • A twitter soaring in the chart with 1 Billion worth of valuation doesn't imply that its love by the majority already. This article just proves on twitter can improve if they will embrace the power of teen-aged viewers.

    detailed sources: Twitter: with 1 BIllion worth of valuation, is it worth it?

    lately, its been said that twitter is not gaining anymore new users, could the "twitter for youth" be the remedy of the "blue-chick's" sickness?
  • I'm 37 and it took me a long time to warm to Twitter. I mean a LONG time. I took up Facebook etc all pretty quickly, but couldn't get my head around Twitter for ages, even as a promotional tool. I think I'm getting the hang of it now, but I get where these teens are coming from...